In April 2003 the Bahraini Government
broke Batelco’s monopoly in telecommunications by awarding a mobile phone
operating license to MTC-Vodafone, a joint venture between MTC of Kuwait and
the United Kingdom’s Vodafone. MTC-Vodafone begins operations early next year.
By the time that happens, the Bahraini Government will have awarded licenses
in just about every other sector of the telecommunications industry, from
Internet services to fixed lined telephony.
Do not underestimate the significance of
this move. Bahrain is the first Gulf country to open its telecommunications
sector to foreign competition. Even the UAE, by many measures the most liberal
country in the region, has categorically refused to allow foreign (or for that
matter domestic) competition in the communications sector.
Why is this so important? Because over
the past three decades, the telecoms industry has emerged as the definitive
bellwether of economic liberalization. Time and again in country after
country, it has proved to be the catalyst for sweeping changes in the business
climate. Bahrain’s telecoms revolution epitomizes the changes that are
transforming Bahrain’s business architecture. The reality on the ground is
that the cold winds of competition are sweeping away the bad habits of the
past. It is coming down to fundamentals: service, ability to cut costs, a good
product.
Is this change good news for the
Bahraini economy? Or will local companies be forced out of business by a wave
of leaner, larger global competitors? The early indicators are promising. The
Bahraini economy is booming, profits of established local companies are
soaring, and a new spirit of entrepreneurship is gripping the country, with
business start-ups appearing every day.
But there are underlying risks that must
not be ignored. The current boom is underpinned by three factors that cannot
be sustained indefinitely: high public spending, high oil prices and low
interest rates. The question is can this boom be sustained once one or more of
these stimulants dries up?
Bahrain is in the grip of an economic boom. Whichever indicator you look at,
it paints a rosy picture. Take real GDP growth, perhaps the most fundamental
assessment of a country’s economic health. Last year it was 5.1%—high by
international standards. This year, forecasts show it will be even stronger,
touching 6.5%.
GDP growth rates on this scale are not
uncommon in the Gulf—wild fluctuations in oil prices and output among major
oil producing nations such as Kuwait and Saudi Arabia make them a fact of
life. Bahrain stands out because its strong recent performance is not a
function of oil markets. Rather, it is based on solid, domestic fundamentals.
It is believed by some experts that
Bahrain is one of the most diversified economies in the region. In terms of
its vulnerability to oil price shocks, it is pretty well protected. GDP growth
volatility is one of the lowest in the region. You don’t get the big swings
that you get in some of the Gulf States.
A large increase in public spending is
underpinning the current upswing. The government has taken a strategic
decision to boost investment spending in the short term in a bid to build the
infrastructure and cash-generating industries needed to support the country in
the medium and long term.
Crucially, this public investment
spending is translating into real profits for Bahraini companies. The
benchmark Bahrain Stock Exchange (BSE) index has risen some 10% this year,
closing at 2,054 points on 11 September 2003. That’s a healthy gain, but it
masks the full extent of the country’s stockmarket success; which should be
more like 20-30% across the board.
Bahrain’s economy has performed well in
recent years due to relatively high world oil prices, increasing volumes of
non-associated natural gas, and robust growth in non-hydrocarbon sectors. In
real terms, GDP expanded on average by an estimated five per cent annually in
2000-02, while the non-hydrocarbon sectors grew by a slightly faster 5.2% per
year over the same period. "Growth has outpaced population growth, thereby
raising per capita incomes.
The Bahraini Government remains highly dependant on oil revenue to fund public
spending. The Kingdom’s GDP may be relatively well diversified, but that does
not extend to the fiscal sector. As such, Bahrain suffers from the same
structural weakness as all its Gulf neighbors. Some 70% of government revenues
come from oil. The problem is that the amount of oil they are shipping out is
in decline. Given that we expect oil prices to fall, that could be a weakness.
Despite significant progress
diversifying the economy away from oil and gas, hydrocarbons remain the
mainstay of the economy. Oil and gas account for around 20% of GDP, 68% of
merchandise export receipts, and more than 60% of budget revenue. Moreover,
government services, which are financed largely by oil proceeds, account for
21% of non-hydrocarbon GDP.
The growth of non-oil sectors has not
translated into higher budgetary revenues due to the absence of a developed
tax system. This is unlikely to change much going forward due to official
concerns that broadening the tax base would erode Bahrain’s competitive
position in the region. Public finances, external accounts, and much of the
real economy are therefore vulnerable to fluctuations in oil prices.
One of Bahrain’s most pressing
weaknesses is unemployment. The precise level of unemployment is not clear,
but it is estimated at well in excess of 10%. The unemployment situation in
some sectors of society is an issue. If you look at the demographics, around
40% of the population is below 15 years of age. They have got to find jobs for
these people, but they are going to enter a situation where there is already
high unemployment. And if you look at some of the industries they are
investing in, such as aluminum, these are capital-intensive but labor-light.
The increasingly liberal commercial landscape in Bahrain is throwing up a
string of openings across the business spectrum. From major international
investors such as the UK’s Vodafone, to small start-ups by Bahraini
entrepreneurs, opportunity knocks in and around Manama. The imminent arrival
of Bahrain’s first Formula One Grand Prix race in April 2004 is the icing on
the cake.
What is being seen is a growth in
entrepreneurs. People are thinking ‘we can get in here’. They can spot an
angle; spot a niche that hasn’t been developed. We are seeing it even with
large established family firms. They are looking for anything a bit different
that their competitors are not doing in the market; spotting an extra service
that could be provided.
There are a lot of small companies just
starting up. That is very nice to see—someone putting their own capital at
risk, and working hard to make something a success. They cross industry
sectors. Small industrial is one area, but also the service sector.
In particular, Bahrain is witnessing a
surge in niche downstream activity relating to its large industrial sectors,
such as aluminum. Entrepreneurs are spotting opportunities to add another link
to the value chain. People have built up the expertise, working for these
large companies over a number of years. Now they are looking to leverage that
expertise as entrepreneurs.
It’s a similar story in financial
services. In particular, Bahrain is emerging as a global center for innovation
in Islamic finance. The government is taking a lead, through the Bahrain
Monetary Agency by helping to establish the world’s first Islamic money
market. This is presenting a number of opportunities in the private sector. We
are continuing to see the increase in Islamic banking; that is encouraging a
number of budding entrepreneurs.
Bahrain’s domestic banking sector
enjoyed a strong first half of 2003. A host of factors contributed to the
sector’s impressive performance, including low interest rates and strong
domestic economic growth.
"Margins for banks improved quite a
bit," says Shahid Hameed, head of asset management at SICO. Commercial banks
have benefited because spreads have increased substantially. Lending rates
have not decreased as much as cost of funding. Also, with interest rates
lowering, loan demand increases. At the same time, asset quality improves. So
you have three factors: margins have increased; demand has increased and asset
quality has improved.
Bahrain-based Ahli United Bank (AUB)
reported 2003 first-half net profit up 51% on the same period last year, to
$49.4 million. This strong result has been achieved through the over
performance of AUB’s retail, corporate and Treasury activities. It has been
assisted by a continuing favorable interest rate environment as well as by
successful proprietary transactions.
National Bank of Bahrain saw net income
rise 14% to BD 13.2 million for the first six months of 2003. Profit at Bank
of Bahrain and Kuwait rose 16% to BD 11.9 million. However, some of the
country’s offshore investment banks continued to suffer the fallout from the
bursting of the U.S. securities bubble in 2000. In early September, ratings
agency Moody’s Investors Service withdrew its rating of Bahrain International
Bank and BMB Investment Bank after they failed to file financial results. Both
banks have been in default for around a year; they defaulted on their loans
after recording heavy losses on U.S. and European investment portfolios.
There was better news for the country’s
larger investment banks. The recovery in the U.S. and European markets saw
half year operating income at Arab Banking Corp. increase to $157 million for
the first half of the year, 16% higher than the $135 million generated in the
first half of 2002. Investcorp also claimed to have performed well during the
period, although changes in the bank’s financial reporting structure make
direct, year-on-year comparisons difficult.
Perhaps the most impressive of Bahrain’s
slew of mega-projects currently being undertaken is the billion-dollar Bahrain
Financial Harbor (BFH). Futuristic in appearance and pragmatic in application,
BFH is far more than a glamorous real estate project. In the worlds of Prime
Minister Sheikh Khalifa bin Salman Al Khalifa, BFH aims to create a
"harmonized and sophisticated climate for a futuristic financial environment
that will be based on the latest and most modern finance-related
infrastructure".
As a financial city, BFH will be the
first of its kind in the Middle East. With a site area of 202,272 square
meters totally reclaimed from the sea, BFH will be located at Manama’s Old
Harbor and will expand eastward, westward and into the sea. BFH will comprise
a community of financial institutions, investment companies and corporations;
will house institutions operating in capital and retail banking markets, asset
management and insurance; and will also provide residential accommodation and
leisure facilities.
While the Bahrain Government has taken a
keen interest in the Harbor, it only has a minority share in the project. As a
private sector initiative, the major shareholders are Qatar Islamic Bank,
Dubai Islamic Bank, Shamil Bank of Bahrain and Gulf Finance House, who have
agreed in principle to finance between $150 million and $200 million of the
development at this stage.
On a grander scale, BFH represents an
unprecedented opportunity for Bahrain’s thriving financial services sector to
flourish. The development will add a new cohesion and professionalism to the
sector—the largest contributor to Bahrain’s GDP. BFH will offer Bahrain a
platform to build on its dominant regional position in finance and banking.
In this regard, the country’s skilled,
indigenous pool of financial talent could prove critical. One of Bahrain’s key
defining factors is that it has a national workforce with decades of
experience in financial services. It doesn’t need to import financial service
professionals from abroad. That makes a huge difference. If the financial
companies want to hire staff, there are plenty of Bahrainis who have worked in
that sector.
Internationally, new trading
opportunities are opening up all the time for Bahraini exporters. The biggest
story on this is the proposed Free Trade Agreement with the United States. The
signing of the agreement led to remarkable export performance for Jordan. It
will certainly help Bahrain in manufacturing. One thing that is unclear is how
that is going to work with GCC customs union.
Customs union itself is a significant
opportunity, particularly for the private sector. Saudi Arabia is an ongoing
opportunity—how they tap into that is absolutely critical. There are a lot of
opportunities just sitting there.