In 1979, when Standard Bank published
Pioneer Bank in a Pioneer Land, the title of the corporate history had a
distinctly nostalgic feel. South Africa’s largest bank – then an offshoot of
Standard Chartered of the UK – might have spent much of its early days
breaking new ground as it followed Cecil Rhodes and other gold diggers around
Africa. But by the end of the 1970s it was on the defensive, labouring under
economic sanctions and heavily reliant on its domestic market.
It took another decade before F.W. de
Klerk told the white parliament, 20 years ago on Tuesday, that its days of
domination were over.
But with democratic South Africa now
more open to the rest of the world, the pioneer label is once again
appropriate for Standard, which is increasingly orienting itself to the
resource-rich African continent and big emerging markets, in particular the
“Brics” – Brazil, Russia, India and China.
The bank’s shift in strategy is just
part of a growing trend in South African business. This period of expansion
abroad embraces not only mining companies, which have traditionally had a more
international focus, but sectors ranging from finance to retailing,
telecommunications and consumer goods and services.
“It is an orthodoxy,” says Jacko Maree,
Standard’s chief executive, who in the past three years has orchestrated
multibillion-dollar deals with Industrial and Commercial Bank of China and
Troika, Russia’s second-largest investment bank. “When [South African
companies] expand they look at emerging markets.” Standard sold a 20 per cent
stake to ICBC in 2007 and acquired one-third of Troika last year.
Bric investment into South Africa is
less pronounced than in some other parts of the continent – indeed, $5.5bn
(£3.4bn, €4bn) of China’s $7bn investment is accounted for by the Standard
deal. But trade connections are strengthening. Last year, China established
itself as the country’s biggest trading partner, displacing Germany.
Barred from doing business in most of
Africa during the apartheid era, South African companies are meanwhile making
up for lost time in their own continent. Links with other emerging markets –
themselves interested in Africa’s resources and high-growth consumer markets –
are growing quickly. The economic momentum is also giving substance to a
foreign policy that since the end of apartheid has favoured links with Asia,
Latin America and Africa in an effort to reduce a historical dependence on
Europe and the US.
“South Africa is becoming the corporate
captain of Africa because it has more pan-African companies than any other
country in Africa and this gives it a seat at the table of the Brics,” says
Michael Power at Investec Asset Management in Cape Town.
Growing connections with emerging
markets in part reflect the long-term shift of an economy that remains heavily
dependent on whoever is demanding its raw materials exports – and the way in
which the global crisis has hobbled Europe and the US, while the east and
south have been less affected. Mineral and raw material exporters have seen
rising Chinese demand for their products help compensate for the slide
elsewhere.
Coal and iron ore exporters – often part
of big international groups such as Anglo American – have been particular
beneficiaries. So have platinum miners. In 2008, about two-thirds of the
platinum dug out of the ground was used to make catalytic converters, a
component that makes vehicle exhaust emissions cleaner. Last year, the motor
industry downturn led to a sharp fall in sales – but platinum producers were
able to sell huge quantities of the metal to jewellery producers in China,
where demand for the so-called white gold is strong.
In addition, though, companies in other
sectors have been stepping up their expansion. Standard itself has been busy
expanding in Africa, recently obtaining a licence in Angola. These
arrangements have enhanced its capacity to negotiate project finance, mining
deals and trade facilities, often – as in the case of a power station being
built by the Chinese in Botswana – with a partner from one of the Brics.
For financial services groups, exchange
controls and tight regulation meant the sector has emerged little scathed from
the crisis and well placed to move forward. Last June, for example, FirstRand
announced it would refocus activities on Africa and the region’s growing trade
and investment links with India and China, agreeing a month later a strategic
alliance with China Construction Bank. Like ICBC, CCB ranks among the big four
Chinese banks.
The trend is also visible among consumer
companies. SAB Miller, the brewer, invested in China as long ago as 1994 and
is now stepping up its drive into Africa. MTN, the elecommunications group
that has sought and failed in the past few years to merge with India’s Bharti
Airtel (on two occasions) and Reliance (on one), has nonetheless made headway
expanding in Africa and in the Middle East. It commands an average 38 per cent
share of 10 markets ranging from Nigeria and Ivory Coast to Afghanistan and
Syria, has more than 100m subscribers and generates 60 per cent of its
revenues outside South Africa.
Even companies that were formerly
bastions of apartheid have been joining the throng. Naspers, a publishing
group of Afrikaner origins, has been picking up media, communications and
especially internet businesses in Brazil, China, Russia and other high-growth
markets – last September buying Brazil’s BuscaPé, a profitable electronic
commerce company, for $342m. Naspers also owns a stake in Tencent, a big
Chinese internet portal.
Sasol, which under white rule developed
technology to convert coal into oil to mitigate the impact of the
international block on sales of crude to South Africa, has struck agreements
within the past two years to develop plants in countries including China,
India, Uzbekistan and Indonesia.
South African companies have been able
to take advantage of these trends for several reasons. Perhaps most important
is the country’s business culture. South African managers are seen as less
risk-averse than their counterparts in Europe and the US. The country’s ethnic
diversity and tumultuous recent history means they also tend to be open to
different cultures and less dogmatic about business methods. Companies have
become adept at working with local partners, influencing the course of a
venture even though they might not have total control.
The very isolation of the apartheid era
forced business to be creative, but post-apartheid trends have helped, too.
Black economic empowerment, a policy introduced in the 1990s under which an
elite of black managers was created and billions of dollars of corporate
equity transferred to black business, has made South African companies more
acceptable in Africa and other emerging markets. Companies have meanwhile
acquired experience in selling their products to South Africa’s own emerging
black middle class and low-income groups, arming them to operate in similar
markets further afield. “South African business isn’t as afraid of Africa as
its competitors. They know what does and does not work and I think proximity
helps as well,” says Mr Power.
Size is another factor. With a
population of less than 50m, South Africa’s domestic market is far smaller
than the giant emerging economies, forcing companies to be flexible rather
than focus on volume. Yet local capital markets are relatively large compared
with economic output, allowing companies to get hold of funds more easily than
some of their developing country competitors. Capitalisation of the
Johannesburg stock market is roughly twice gross domestic product, whereas in
many countries the value of listed companies is smaller than the yearly output
of the overall economy.
The country also has sophisticated debt
markets on which companies can raise long-term funds. “South Africa has by far
the most sophisticated capital market compared to [other developing
economies]. You had an ability to fund yourself that was disproportionate to
the size of the home base,” says Standard’s Mr Maree. On top of all that,
companies have been urged by their government to do business in emerging
markets. Since the mid-1990s the governing African National Congress has
wanted to promote a southern axis, linking the big emerging nations and
Africa. In part, that is to keep US political domination in check by
strengthening multilateral institutions.
Seven years ago, South Africa joined
Brazil and India to form the G3, also known as Ibsa. Although its economy is
by far the smallest of the three, the country’s influence within Africa gives
South Africa disproportionate weight, making it an attractive partner for the
Brics
when they seek to exercise diplomatic
muscle. That influence was visible late last year in Copenhagen when South
Africa – alongside Brazil, India and China – took an active role in climate
change negotiations, giving birth to the so-called Basic group.
It will take time for these connections
to develop. The government is wary of a high degree of dependence on any
country and insists national interests have to be taken into account, with
leaders warning about the dangers of a new colonial relationship. Indeed, the
government imposed temporary quotas on Chinese textile imports in 2007 and
2008. In the eventually unsuccessful negotiations about merging MTN and Bharti
Airtel, South Africa jealously defended the idea that the new entity should be
listed in Johannesburg as well as Mumbai, in spite of the greater scale of the
Indian undertaking.
No longer is it likely that globalising
South African companies will be allowed to list their shares and move their
headquarters abroad, as groups including Anglo American and SAB did in the
late 1990s by relocating to London. But even so, say analysts, the country’s
corporate sector offers investors keen on the potential of the Brics a
different way to access those markets. Because South African companies tend to
be more transparent and better governed than many of their emerging market
counterparts, it could also be a safer way to benefit.
Ayanda Ntsaluba, director general at the
foreign ministry in Pretoria, says the government regularly holds discussions
with companies such as Standard and MTN, and lends particular backing to
co-operation between these businesses and Chinese, Indian or Brazilian
counterparts. “We are encouraging more South African companies to establish
themselves in the emerging world,” he adds.